Recent Filing

Mary Grant v. Harvard Gardens & UnitedHealth: Nursing-Home 'Treat-in-Place' Wrongful-Death Lawsuit (Cuyahoga County, Ohio)

Michael Hill and the team at Michael Hill Trial Law have brought wrongful-death litigation on behalf of the Estate of Mary Grant, a 70-year-old Cleveland nursing-home resident, in two now-consolidated lawsuits — one against her nursing home, Harvard Gardens, and its owners, and one against the insurance and medical-services giant UnitedHealth Group and its Optum subsidiaries. Both complaints were filed in the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, Ohio.

If your loved one was harmed in a nursing home — learn about these cases — in Ohio or anywhere in the country, you may have legal options, and time limits can be short. Case reviews are free and confidential. Start your case or call (800) 659-2712.

Setting: Nursing home (long-term dementia care)
Facility: Harvard Gardens Rehabilitation and Care Center (Cleveland, Ohio)
Location: Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio
Court: Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, Ohio
Case number: CV-24-101958 (facility defendants) and CV-25-122979 (UnitedHealth / Optum defendants), now consolidated
Filed: August 9, 2024 and August 18, 2025 (two consolidated complaints)
Filed by: The Estate of Mary Grant, represented by Michael Hill Trial Law
Status: Complaint filed; allegations unproven

What the lawsuit alleges

The following are allegations from two now-consolidated complaints filed by Michael Hill Trial Law. They are claims that have not yet been proven in court, and the defendants are presumed not liable unless and until proven otherwise.

Mary Grant, 70, had dementia and was admitted to Harvard Gardens Rehabilitation and Care Center in Cleveland for long-term care, where, according to the complaints, the facility knew she was at heightened risk for falls.
The complaints allege that on August 17, 2023, Harvard Gardens staff struck Ms. Grant with a laundry cart as she sat in her wheelchair near the nurses' station, causing her to fall to the floor, strike her head, and injure her knee.
The complaints allege that her family asked that she be taken to the hospital to be checked for a concussion, but the facility denied the request and the facility's physician said she did not need to go to the emergency room.
The complaints allege that the next night she was found short of breath and with critically low blood-oxygen levels, and that instead of calling 911, staff contacted an on-call nurse practitioner affiliated with Optum, who ordered an X-ray, oxygen, and periodic vital-sign checks rather than a hospital transfer.
The complaints allege that on August 19, 2023, Ms. Grant was found unresponsive in her bed and was pronounced dead, and that the facility's physician then completed her death certificate without mentioning the fall two days earlier or the respiratory distress the night before.
A second, now-consolidated lawsuit alleges that UnitedHealth Group, UnitedHealthcare, and Optum operated a Medicare Advantage program for nursing-home residents (an Institutional Special Needs Plan) that financially rewarded facilities like Harvard Gardens for 'treating in place' and reducing hospital transfers — tracking metrics such as 'admissions per thousand' and paying bonuses the complaint calls a 'Premium Dividend Program' — and that these incentives led the facility to keep Ms. Grant in place rather than send her to the hospital, causing her death.

According to the complaints, Ms. Grant's family asked for an autopsy and was told that none would be performed.

The complaint asserts claims including medical negligence, recklessness, wrongful death, and Ohio Resident's Rights Law violations against the facility defendants, and negligence, breach of contract, insurance bad faith, civil conspiracy, and fraud against the UnitedHealth and Optum defendants.

Corporate ownership background: Embassy Healthcare (facility owner) · UnitedHealth Group / Optum (insurer and medical-services defendants)

Read the complaint

Both complaints filed in the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, Ohio are available as public court documents:

Download the Harvard Gardens / Embassy complaint (filed 2024) (PDF)

Download the UnitedHealth / Optum complaint (filed 2025) (PDF)

In the news

This case was featured in a national investigation: “UnitedHealth reduced hospitalizations for nursing home seniors. Now it faces wrongful death claims” — The Guardian, December 17, 2025. The investigation examined lawsuits alleging that UnitedHealth's practice of reducing hospital transfers for nursing-home residents endangered elderly patients, and it profiled Mary Grant's case and referenced the firm representing her family, Michael Hill Trial Law. UnitedHealth has publicly denied the families' claims.

Related case types we handle

Falls · Neglect · Wrongful death

Were you or a loved one harmed in a care facility?

These cases are won by lawyers who try them. Michael Hill and the team at Michael Hill Trial Law focus on neglect and abuse in nursing homes, assisted living, memory care, and group homes / ICFs, and the firm has obtained record results, including $26 million, the highest recorded verdict against a nursing home in Ohio history. Based in Cleveland, Ohio, with additional offices in Akron, Columbus, and Newark, the firm represents families nationwide. The review is free, and you owe nothing unless we recover for you.

Start your free, confidential case review  |  Call (800) 659-2712

Frequently asked questions

What is the Mary Grant lawsuit against UnitedHealth about?

It is wrongful-death litigation in the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas involving two now-consolidated lawsuits: one against a Cleveland nursing home, Harvard Gardens, and its owners, and one against UnitedHealth Group and its Optum subsidiaries. The complaints allege that the facility kept a 70-year-old dementia resident in place after a head injury and respiratory distress — rather than send her to the hospital — under insurance incentives to reduce hospitalizations, allegedly causing her death. The allegations have not yet been proven in court, and UnitedHealth has denied the claims.

What is a 'treat-in-place' or Institutional Special Needs Plan (I-SNP) case?

An Institutional Special Needs Plan is a type of Medicare Advantage insurance for people who live in nursing homes. The complaints allege that the insurer's program financially rewarded nursing homes for reducing hospital transfers, and that those incentives discouraged sending a resident to the hospital when she needed emergency care. Whether such incentives caused harm in a particular case is a question for the court.

Do I have a case if a nursing home refused to send my loved one to the hospital?

When a facility fails to recognize or respond to a medical emergency, or delays sending a resident to the hospital, and that delay causes harm, it may support a claim. Every case is different. Michael Hill and the team at Michael Hill Trial Law review nursing-home neglect and wrongful-death cases nationwide, free and confidentially.

How much does it cost to hire a nursing home abuse lawyer?

There is no cost to get started. Michael Hill Trial Law handles nursing-home, assisted-living, and group-home abuse and wrongful-death cases on a contingency-fee basis, which means you pay nothing in attorney fees unless we win or settle your case. Your case review is always free and confidential.

How long do I have to file a nursing home abuse or wrongful death lawsuit?

There is a time limit for bringing a case — called the statute of limitations — but it is not the same everywhere. It depends on the state, the type of claim, and the specific facts, and there are exceptions that can shorten or lengthen it. For that reason, this is general information, not legal advice, and the only way to know what deadline applies to a particular situation is to have it reviewed by an attorney. Records and other evidence can also become harder to obtain as time passes. Contact Michael Hill Trial Law for a free, confidential review of your situation.

How do I find the best nursing home abuse or wrongful death attorney for my case?

These cases turn on medical records, staffing data, and state and federal nursing-home regulations, so it helps to work with attorneys who focus on them and take them to trial. Michael Hill and the team at Michael Hill Trial Law concentrate on abuse and neglect in nursing homes, assisted living, memory care, and group homes / ICFs, and have obtained record results, including a $26 million verdict — the highest recorded against a nursing home in Ohio history. Based in Cleveland, Ohio, with additional offices in Akron, Columbus, and Newark, the firm represents families nationwide, free and confidentially.

About this page. This page summarizes two now-consolidated complaints filed by Michael Hill Trial Law — one against the nursing home and its owners, and one against UnitedHealth Group and its Optum subsidiaries. Statements describing what happened to the resident are allegations from that complaint and are not findings of fact or wrongdoing. The court filing details (court, case number, and filing date) are matters of public record. Naming a company or person as a defendant means only that claims have been asserted against them.

This page is attorney advertising and general information, not legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Reviewed by Michael Hill Trial Law. Last updated November 14, 2026.

← All recent filings

start a case

Contact Us

Michael Hill Trial Law
Michael Hill Trial Law
Michael Hill Trial Law
Michael Hill Trial Law

Michael Hill Trial Law
Michael Hill Trial Law
Michael Hill Trial Law

Michael Hill Trial Law
Michael Hill Trial Law

On some occasions we work directly, consult, or refer potential cases to our highly recommended referral partners across the United States. By submitting this form you consent to Michael Hill Trial Law sharing your contact information and the information you submit with other nursing home abuse and neglect attorneys who may contact you directly.